Carol
M. White Physical Education for
Progress Grant
(Formally known as
the PEP Grant)
|
Project Rising Expectations:
Institutionalizing Change For Lifetime Fitness
|
NEED FOR THE PROJECT |
1(a). Specific gaps or weaknesses
The Eugene School District is Oregon’s fourth largest school
district, with a student population of nearly 18,000. The district
has twenty-three elementary schools, eight middle schools and four
high schools. Twenty-six percent of students live in households
below the poverty level as measured by participation in the free
and reduced price lunch program.
Like many other states, Oregon has been hit hard by the down-turned
economy. Massive state budget shortfalls have had a major impact
on school funding. The result has been a 46% reduction in physical
education staffing in Eugene since1989, burgeoning class sizes,
a reduction of physical education requirements, elimination of intramural
programs, reduction of middle school athletic programs from four
sports to one, introduction of high school participation fees of
nearly $100 per sport, and few affordable opportunities for safe
supervised after-school activity.
There is reason to be hopeful, however. Although Oregon school districts
are legislatively prohibited from raising money locally to support
their programs, cities are not. Last year, the citizens of Eugene
demonstrated their concern about the health crisis facing community
youth and their support for Eugene students by passing a four-year
special city levy for district youth activities and services, including
physical education. These funds will help our district weather the
state’s fiscal crisis and protect against further cuts in
physical education staffing.
Because of substantial budget reductions over the last 15 years,
the amount of time spent by students in physical education has decreased
significantly. The typical elementary student receives an average
of 50 minutes weekly, most middle schools require daily PE for 6th
graders with 7th and 8th grade elective, while high schools have
a 1-year PE graduation requirement. Staff are quite anxious about
the limited time students spend in their physical education classes
and the impact that has on the attainment of benchmarks. The district
recognizes a strong need to partner with community agencies and
businesses in an attempt to provide more opportunity for healthy
and meaningful physical activity in an effort to help our students
attain benchmark proficiency and improve lifestyle habits and fitness.
In addition to program reductions, budgets for equipment, supplies,
and staff development have diminished significantly. In a survey
of K-12 physical education staff (April, 2003), teachers reported
budget reductions had left them unable to replace worn equipment,
provide adequate sets of equipment in classes of increased size,
or purchase new equipment and technology to bring programs in line
with national trends and the newly adopted Oregon Content and Student
Performance Standards for Physical Education. Sixty two percent
of teachers found their equipment adequate for team sport and games
(Expressive and Efficient Movement strand of the Oregon standards),
but only 29% found equipment adequate in the areas of lifetime fitness
and outdoor adventure (Fitness for Life strand) while nearly half
responded they lacked adequate equipment and resources to teach
to the Self Management and Social Behavior strand of the Oregon
standards.
District staff development for physical education over the past
15 years has been minimal. Lack of staff development, combined with
decentralization and movement to site-based management, left physical
educators feeling isolated and fostered a stagnant district physical
education program. We have a pressing need for high quality and
on-going professional development to foster common vision and articulation
between programs.
In the fall of 2001, Oregon adopted Content and Student Performance
Standards for Physical Education. Curriculum content and benchmarks
for what students must know and be able to do are organized under
three strands: Efficient and Expressive Movement, Fitness For A
Lifetime, and Social Behavior and Self Management.
Eugene’s physical education programs have been dominated by
traditional competitive team sports. Curriculum mapping in Spring,
2002 indicated 70% of middle and high school programs centered around
traditional team sport activity. A student survey (April, 2003)
indicated that only 43% of students in grades 6-12 would choose
this type of activity as their first choice. Females indicated a
much lower preference for traditional team sport. The district Adaptive
Physical Education Team reported that the sport model makes it especially
difficult to include students with disabilities. The sport model
fails to meet the needs and interests and of all students, fails
to adequately address the comprehensive state content standards
and fails to help students understand the relevance of physical
activity to their daily lives, To be candid, lack of adequate funding
in our school district for program staffing, equipment, and ongoing
professional development has created an outdated and inadequate
physical education program for students.
The curriculum mapping and teacher surveys we have collected indicate
a major disconnect between existing programs and the state standards.
Benchmark standards under the Expressive and Efficient Movement
strand require students to demonstrate competency in three or more
movement categories: Individual activities; dual activities; aerobic/cardiovascular
lifetime activities; outdoor pursuits; dance, self defense, yoga,
martial arts; team sports; strength training and conditioning; and
aquatics. Curriculum mapping indicated few student opportunities
outside of the team sport, strength training/conditioning, and dual
activity categories. Opportunities in outdoor pursuits, lifetime
activities, dance, and aquatics are scarce. Teacher feedback indicated
little or no attention given to developing the benchmark skills
of critiquing skills/performance or applying principles of training
to a variety of skills as required under the Movement strand. Curriculum
mapping and teacher survey results indicate little systematic health-related
fitness assessment. Little attention is given to teaching cognitive
concepts to enable students to become self-managers of their personal
fitness. Only one middle school program and one high school program
ask students to design a personal fitness plan based on a fitness
assessment and developed goals required by the Fitness For A Lifetime
strand of the Oregon standards. Programming at all levels shows
a significant lack of cooperative activity. Opportunities for team
building and problem solving through movement activities are seldom
present.
Under the state standards legislation, local school districts were
charged with the responsibility of developing and implementing benchmark
assessments for all three strands of the standards beginning with
the 2003-2004 school year. Because there was no funding for this
work, most districts struggled, and as a result, new legislation
eliminated the required student assessments. Recognizing the importance
of this task to the revitalization of the district physical education
program, however, Eugene moved forward to complete a comprehensive
set of assessment protocols with rubrics and scoring guides for
all three strands. According to the Oregon Department of Education,
we are the only school district to do so and hope to become a lighthouse
district for other LEA’s in Oregon. The district phase-in
timetable calls for piloting assessments for one strand of the standards
in the spring of 2004.
Like the nation as a whole, Oregon is facing a health crisis among
adults, children, and youth. Oregon has the highest obesity rate
of any state west of the Rockies: twenty-two percent (Oregon Coalition
for Promoting Physical Activity, 2003). Sample testing of 8th grade
students (Eugene, 2002) indicated that 33% are overweight with 18%
being obese and 64% of those obese being female. Obesity puts students
at an elevated risk of teen pregnancy, substance abuse, and drop
out along with obvious health issues. An April 2002 survey of Eugene
K-12 students indicated that by the end of the 8th grade, 24% of
students do not meet the Surgeon General’s definition of an
active individual with that number rising to over 33% by the end
of grade 12.
The 2003 Eugene Healthy Teen Survey (See Appendix 2: Survey)
indicates many students have adopted unhealthy eating behaviors
in an effort to control weight. Nutrition education has been another
victim of dwindling district financial resources. At the same time
nutrition education has been neglected, contracts with major soft
drink and vending machine companies and ala carte lines in school
lunch programs have enabled students to make unhealthy food choices.
Inadequate activity combined with poor nutrition has created a significant
health issue for our students. The Eugene Register Guard
reports deaths caused by poor diet and lack of activity are second
only to those related to tobacco (March 10, 2004). We know there
is a direct correlation between fitness and academic achievement
(California Dept. of Education, 2002).
During spring of 2003, the Eugene School District identified several
critical needs of the district physical education program. Based
on these needs, the Eugene School District received a Carol M. White
PEP Grant for the 2003-2004 school year. Our grant project had four
primary goals 1) To increase opportunities for participation in
standards-based lifetime and non-traditional activities designed
to foster student understanding and valuing of physical activity
and its role in maintaining a healthy lifestyle over the lifespan
(Strands 1 and 2 of the Oregon Standards); 2) Provide on-going
professional development and the needed equipment and supplies to
implement a wide range of health-related lifetime activities aimed
at increasing student interest and enthusiasm for physical activity
(Strands 1, 2,and 3); 3)To develop new school-community
partnerships to provide curriculum relevance and student connection
to community-based activity opportunities (Strands 1 and 2);
and 4)To increase parent opportunities to support their children’s
participation in meaningful health-related lifetime activity (Strand
2). The 2003-2004 PEP Grant provided a solid jumping off point
in addressing our needs. Table 1 outlines project activities.
Table 1: New Activities
in the current 2003-2004 Rising Expectations Project |
| Elementary |
Middle School |
High School |
| Physical Best Program |
Physical Best Program |
Physical Best Program |
| Fitnessgram/Activitygram |
Fitnessgram/Activitygram |
Fitnessgram/Activitygram |
Fitness Technology: Pedometers,
Pyramid Challenge |
Fitness Technology: Pedometers,
Heart rate monitors, Pyramid Challenge |
Fitness Technology:
Heart rate monitors |
| Heart Adventure Course |
Golf |
Golf |
| In-line skating |
In-line skating |
In-line skating |
New non-traditional
standards-based activities |
New non-traditional
standards-based activities |
New non-traditional
standards-based activities |
| Project Adventure |
Project Adventure |
N.A. |
Rock Climbing
(low bouldering) |
|
N.A. |
To date, we have successfully addressed many of the needs. However,
one year was not a long enough period to fully develop the comprehensive
program we are seeking to establish in this year’s PEP application.
After years of neglect, the district physical education program
needs more than a one-time transfusion of monies. Economic challenges
to our programs continue, as our state has not recovered from its
economic woes. The current grant has been successful in introducing
staff to a wide array of new activities and new program philosophy.
However, moving staff from well-ingrained patterns is not an easy
or quick process. The staff is overwhelmed with new information.
Research shows that the most important factor affecting student
learning is the teacher (Wright, Horn and Sanders, 1997). Creating
a viable curriculum is heavily influenced by two factors: 1) opportunity
to learn; and 2) time (Marzano, 2003). Length and number of staff
development activities are positively correlated with change in
teacher behavior. The more staff development, the greater the change
in staff behavior (Garet, 2001). To institutionalize the change
that we are trying to instill will require multiple opportunities
to learn and time to process. A recurring theme in the evaluations
of this year’s workshops has been the need for more time to
absorb the material and to follow-up in order to facilitate full
implementation. Based upon 2003-2004 PEP workshop evaluations and
a March 2004 teacher survey, the following needs have been identified:
(1) Ongoing staff development to follow-up this years’ workshops
and to introduce new trainings in order to institutionalize the
change to a comprehensive standards-based program with a balanced
emphasis on all three strands of the Oregon standards; (2) Continued
effort in diversifying activities and aligning district curriculum
with the state standards to better meet the needs and interests
of all students. (3) Continued upgrading of equipment and supplies
to enable students to develop the skills and knowledge to meet benchmark
standards and become lifetime consumers of healthy physical activity;
(4) Ongoing attention to the nutritional education and food choices
of students; (5) Increased involvement of the community in program
goals and activities; (6) Increased opportunities for student achievement
of state standards and more time in standards-based physical activity
through both physical education classes and after school activity
programs;
Based on a review of the 2003-04 project to date, curriculum mapping,
teacher surveys, and best practices for physical education programming,
we have established the following goals for the new project linked
to the three strands of the Oregon Physical Education Standards:
Project Goals:
Goal 1: Physical education programs and after school
programs will increase opportunities for participation in standards-based
lifetime and non-traditional activities designed to foster student
understanding and appreciation of physical activity and its role
in maintaining a healthy lifestyle over the lifespan while preparing
students to meet the Oregon standards.
Goal 2: Standards-based middle school after-school
activity programs will be instituted to help strengthen students’
ability to meet the standards.
Goal 3: All physical education teachers and after
school program staff will receive on-going professional development
and needed equipment and supplies to implement a wide range of health-related
lifetime and non-traditional standards-based activities aimed at
increasing student interest and enthusiasm for physical activity
and to ensure students will meet the standards.
Goal 4: Project staff will develop new school/community
partnerships to provide curriculum relevance and student connection
to community-based activity opportunities that will remain after
the period of funding has ended.
Goal 5: Project staff will increase parent opportunities
to support their children’s participation in meaningful health-related
lifetime activity.
SIGNIFICANCE
2(a). The likelihood that the proposed project will result
in change or improvement.
Project Rising Expectations: Institutionalizing Change will produce
long-term systemic change in the Eugene School District physical
education program and in student opportunities for healthy lifestyle
activity. This project will sustain and institutionalize a major
shift in program philosophy that began this year while responding
to both staff and student needs and interests.
Our district has shown the commitment it takes to make major long-term
change. The physical education staff have embraced the standards
and shown an eagerness for relevant staff development. According
to the State Department of Education, we are the only school district
in Oregon to complete the development of assessment protocols for
all benchmarks under all three strands of the Oregon Standards.
This demonstrates a strong commitment to move our program to a better
place, and the likelihood that real change will occur. Our current
PEP grant has enabled us to develop a solid format for staff development.
The new project will expand staff development so capacity for a
viable program and curriculum can be achieved and institutionalized.
Over 90 hours of staff development will be offered on variety of
standards-based activities to meet the needs and interests of all
students along with equipment resources to fully implement these
activities. The comprehensive plan of staff development opportunities
will cover all three strands of the Oregon standards and all six
program elements of the Carol M. White Physical Education Program.
They will not only offer training in new activities but will provide
training in effective teaching strategies and classroom management.
The project will align all our programs with the state physical
education standards, resulting in both better quality and more equitable
programs, as well as horizontal and vertical articulation among
instructional programs.
Through this project we will partner with the city of Eugene Recreation
Division to provide a standards-based after school activity program.
By combining city levy funds with project funds, we will be able
to extend program staffing to all 4J middle schools. More importantly,
the project will provide standards-based training for city recreation
staff and facilitate a vital new partnership with benefits well
beyond the life of this project as we continue a joint effort to
help students achieve benchmark standards and form lifestyle habits
which extend beyond the school day.
Critical components of this project include the comprehensive health-related
fitness education programs Physical Best and Fitness For Life as
well as the health-related fitness assessment package, Fitnessgram.
These tools will prepare physical education staff to introduce a
strong cognitive component to their programs to provide students
with the skills and knowledge necessary to make positive lifestyle
choices and become self-managers of their personal fitness.
2(b) Promising new strategies
Table 2 illustrates the relationship between the strategies previously
employed by the Eugene physical education programs, progress made
in the current project, the proposed strategies under the new project,
and how the strategies will enhance the current program.
Table 2: How Project
Strategies will Enhance the Current Program |
Previous dominant
strategies in the Eugene School District |
Current situation
after 6 months of current PEP Project |
Project strategies
that build on, or are
alternatives to, existing strategies |
How new project strategies
enhance or change existing district program |
- Traditional team sport and game model of physical education
at all levels K-12
|
- Movement away from team sport emphasis particularly with
in-line skating and increased emphasis in the Fitness Strand.
|
- Continued establishment of non-traditional, cooperative,
and lifetime activities
|
- Enhancement: Comprehensive program with
wide options to engage in physical activity meeting student
interests and needs.
|
- Little or no time spent on cognitive learning related
to lifetime activity and fitness
- Little or no instruction in nutrition
|
- Concepts being taught through Physical Best, Fitnessgram,
Heart Adventure Course and use of heart rate monitors and
pedometers.
- Pyramid Challenge and Pyramid Explorer nutrition software
being introduced to K-6 students.
|
- Specific staff development leading to inclusion of health-related
fitness education into programs (Physical Best follow-up
and introduction of Fitness For Life, gr. 6-12).
- Additional series of grade level specific nutrition education.
|
- Enhancement: Focused academic instruction
in health-related fitness and activity concepts integrated
into the enhanced activity program as well as nutrition
education directed at each grade level (Michigan Model)
|
- Individual teachers seek out staff development opportunities
provided by professional associations without financial
support from district
- After school programs in some middle schools led by rec
leaders with minimal training.
|
- 40 hours of standards-based staff development provided
through current PEP project.
- No change in after-school program.
|
- Continued staff development on adopted programs aligned
to the state standards (i.e., Physical Best, Fitnessgram,
Fitness for Life)
- On-going staff development on inclusion of innovative,
cooperative and lifetime activity as well as technology
- Standards-based activity training for after school program
staff in all 8 middle schools.
|
- Enhancement: Expanded opportunity for
all teachers to engage in on-going district sponsored physical
education staff development aimed at curriculum and standards
alignment and program articulation.
Change: City staff trained in standards-based
activities to allow them to partner with school staff in
helping students meet standards
|
- Paper and pencil recording of student fitness scores with
no data kept year to year
|
- Staff currently in the process of learning Fitnessgram
to collect student data.
|
- Systemic use of technology in both the measurement and
recording of fitness data over time (Fitnessgram and Heart
Rate Monitors)
|
- Enhancement: Maximum use of technology
for better assessment, monitoring and recording of student
progress
|
- No systematic assessment of fitness /skills, assessment
tools, or consistent performance criteria for student performance
|
- Teachers have begun the piloting of assessments for one
strand of the physical education standards.
|
- Consistent district-wide performance criteria and assessment
tools addressing all three strands of the Oregon standards
|
- Enhancement: Accurate feedback for students
and parents that facilitates personal fitness planning and
goal monitoring
Change: All teachers will implement assessment
at all benchmark levels.
|
- Teacher initiated partnerships that benefit only some
students
- Limited system of community partnerships
|
- Established partnerships with 2 golf courses, a personal
defense school, and nutrition consulting company.
|
- Expanded commun-ity partnerships, including private organizations
and the City of Eugene (after school standards-based activities
program, week end climbing program and Team Adventure)
|
- Enhancement: All students benefit from
community partnerships.
Enhancement: Students have in-creased opportunities
to pursue lifetime activities in Eugene and the state.
|
2(c) The importance or magnitude of the results
or outcomes
Research clearly indicates the importance of ongoing staff development
to teaching effectiveness and professionalism. This project will
provide our staff with content-focused, active learning, and coherent
staff development delivered by some of our profession’s best.
Research shows that those three features of staff development have
the strongest relationship to reported change in teaching practice
(Garet, 2001). Research also points out that the teacher is the
most critical factor in student learning. Meaningful and regular
staff development is the key to improving programs and instruction.
Staff development provided by this project will institutionalize
real change to a comprehensive standards-based program providing
students with skills, knowledge, and behaviors conducive to a healthy
lifestyle now and in the future.
The standards-based after school program provided through a partnership
with the City of Eugene, proposed in this project, offers students
an opportunity to extend skills and knowledge into the world of
recreation after school. This project facilitates voluntary application
of healthy lifestyle behavior while also moving students closer
to benchmark attainment on the Oregon standards.
While we have established a partnership with two golf courses this
year, which has greatly benefited the school program, this project
will facilitate the further development of partnerships with private
providers of physical activity in our community. These partnerships
will benefit our programs long after the project funding terminates.
The likelihood of successful attainment of the physical education
benchmark standards is strongly enhanced by the opportunity for
students to engage in meaningful movement activities during out-of-school
time.
The technology and cognitive-based curriculum provided through the
project will enhance student achievement on benchmarks related to
understanding, improving, and maintaining their personal fitness
and well-being. The new equipment and supplies will allow schools
to expand curriculum offerings and learning activities to include
lifetime activities of high interest to students. The expansion
of programs resulting from a coherent system of staff development,
school-community partnerships, and the provision of high quality
equipment will restore student enthusiasm for physical education
and an active lifestyle. As the activity and fitness level of students
improve, self-esteem, confidence, academic achievement and lifestyle
choices, such as smoking and alcohol use, will be positively affected
(PE 4 Life, 2002).
Project Rising Expectations: Institutionalizing Change is crucial
to the continued revitalization of the physical education program
of the Eugene School District and critical to changing the health
and lifestyle choices of our students and, ultimately, our community.
QUALITY OF PROJECT DESIGN
The primary goal of Project Rising Expectations: Institutionalizing
Change is to create significant systemic program change in physical
education and activity programming to better enable students to
develop the knowledge, skills and attitudes necessary to become
responsible lifetime consumers of activity and beneficiaries of
personal wellness. The project will provide intensive and ongoing
professional development designed to facilitate the delivery of
quality health-enhancing physical education and after-school programs
tied directly to all three strands of the Oregon Content and Student
Performance Standards for Physical Education. Systematic and coherent
staff development, combined with access to high quality equipment,
supplies, and technology needed for standards-based instruction
and learning will lead to implementation and institutionalization
of this comprehensive new curriculum. The implementation of an assessment
program will provide accurate and meaningful measurement and monitoring
of student progress and provide the personal feedback necessary
for continued learning and motivation. The assessment program will
include benchmark assessment of the Oregon student performance standards
for physical education, regular health-related fitness assessments
utilizing Fitnessgram, and monitoring of student performance through
the use of heart rate and pedometer technology embedded within the
daily instructional program. Continued efforts at developing community
connections and partnerships will provide a sense of relevance to
the program and increase the likelihood of participation by students
in activity outside of the school day.
The Rising Expectations: Institutionalizing Change Project has five
goals targeting the areas of curriculum and instruction, after-school
programming, staff development, community partnerships, and parent
involvement. The goals, measurable objectives, and activities of
the project along with research to support the goals are detailed
below:
Goal 1: Physical education and after-school programs will
increase opportunities for participation in standards-based lifetime
and non-traditional activities designed to develop the knowledge
and skills for a lifetime of activity while fostering student understanding
and appreciation of physical activity and its role in maintaining
a healthy lifestyle over the lifespan.
Objective 1: At least 75% of students will be introduced
to a new activity that they enjoy and had not previously participated
in.
Objective 2: The percentage of students participating
in an average of 30 minutes of moderate physical activity will increase
from 71% to 80%.
Objective 3: Physical education staff will pilot
assessment protocols for The Expressive & Efficient Movement
and Social Behavior & Self Management strands of the Oregon
standards in year one (piloting of fitness strand protocols currently
taking place); 75% of all students will meet benchmarks for the
state student performance standards for physical education in the
first full year of assessment (Year 2 of the project) with 80% meeting
benchmarks in year 3 of the project.
Objective 4: We will create a health-related fitness
profile of the school district in Year 1; the number of overweight
8th grade students will decrease from 33% to 28% by the end of Year
3.
Activities to meet Goal 1 objectives
This project will reinforce and institutionalize the new standards-based
activities introduced in physical education classes during the 2003-2004
school year (Physical Best, Fitnessgram, Heart Rate monitors, Pedometers,
In-line skating, Heart Adventure and Golf) while adding a variety
of new standards-based lifetime activities of high interest to students
and staff such as rock climbing and dance. By developing and advancing
skills and knowledge in enjoyable new activities, student interest
and participation will increase. Positive experience in the new
activities will lead to more frequent participation in health-enhancing
lifetime activity both in and out of school, which will lead to
a reduction in the number of overweight students.
Students will be guided towards fitness independence allowing them
to become self-managers of their personal fitness over time. Students
will have learning experiences in fitness, wellness, and activity
concepts integrated with movement through the research-based Physical
Best program from the American Alliance for Health, Physical Education,
Recreation and Dance. Middle and high school students will receive
coordinated instruction in activity, fitness, and wellness concepts
through the internationally recognized Fitness For Life curriculum
by Corbin and Lindsey. Using Fitnessgram and a variety of technology
tools currently beginning to be introduced into programs, including
pedometers, heart rate monitors and Pyramid Challenge software,
students will master the skills enabling them to self-assess their
personal fitness and monitor their fitness, activity, and nutritional
goals.
Numerous changes and new activities are being introduced into the
existing program this year as a part of our one-year PEP Project
(Table 2). While this project institutes changes across the district,
critical gaps remain. Table 3 illustrates the new activities to
be integrated into the evolving program
.
| Table 3: Reinforced
and New Activities for Rising Expectations: Institutionalizing
Change for Lifetime Fitness |
Elementary School |
Middle School |
High School |
| TeamBuilding/Cooperative Games |
TeamBuilding/Cooperative Games |
TeamBuilding/Cooperative Games |
| New Non-traditional standards-based activities |
New Non-traditional standards-based activities |
New Non-traditional standards-based |
| Cup Stacking |
Fitness for Life |
Fitness for Life |
| Dare to Dance |
Dare to Dance |
Dare to Dance |
| Hip Hop Hip |
Hip Hop Hip |
Rock Climbing |
| Learning Obstacles |
Rock Climbing |
| Circus Sports |
Circus Sports |
| Learning Obstacles |
Staff development and all necessary equipment will
be provided for full implementation of all new activities. A detailed
description of the activities in the table above and their importance
and relationship to the standards is given in the discussion of
the staff development goal.
Research to Support Goal 1:
The Surgeon General’s Report on physical activity and health
(USDHHS, 1996) recommends 30 minutes of moderately vigorous activity
most days of the week to maintain health and wellness (For references,
see Appendix 1). The National Association for Sport and Physical
Education (NASPE) recommends up to 60 minutes of moderately vigorous
activity per day for elementary students. Despite numerous recommendations
and calls for activity, many schools do not require daily participation
in physical education. The Center for Disease Control (CDC) reports
enrollment in daily physical education has dropped from 42% in 1991
to 29% in 1999. CDC reports that almost half of young people aged
12-21 and more than a third of high school students do not participate
in physical education regularly (1997). These findings are consistent
with the research we have completed locally. We recognize that with
time in physical education programs so limited, we must better prepare
students to participate in activity outside of class and to become
lifetime consumers of physical activity. The Surgeon General’s
report of 1996 encourages physical education teachers to incorporate
more meaningful physical activity into physical education. The U.S.
Department of Health and Human Services (2000) recommends that physical
education implement “curricula and instruction that emphasize
enjoyable participation in physical activity and help students develop
the knowledge, attitudes, motor skills, behavioral skills, and confidence
needed to adopt and maintain physically active lifestyles.”
This recommendation for diversity within programs with emphasis
on lifetime activity and fitness is echoed in numerous other publications,
e.g., It’s Not Just Gym Anymore (McCracken, 2001). In its
publications on appropriate practices, NASPE states that the ultimate
goal of physical education is to guide students into being physically
active for a lifetime by providing instruction in a variety of activities
based on student needs and interests. Physical education teachers
need to do business in a different way. As McCracken (2001) concludes,
“[If we] continue to do what we have been doing for the last
two decades, [we] will continue to get the same results: a further
decline in physical activity, lower numbers in physical education,
and a continued rise in health care cost.” Project Rising
Expectations: Institutionalizing Change for Lifetime Fitness represents
a strong commitment to do business in a different way within Eugene’s
physical education programs.
Goal 2: Standards-based middle school after-school activity
programs will be instituted to help strengthen students’ ability
to meet the standards.
Objective 1: All 8 middle schools will initiate standards
based after-school activity programs.
Objective 2: All 8 middle schools will initiate
after school rock climbing programs.
Activities to meet Goal 2 objectives
In partnership with the City of Eugene, a four day per week after-school
activity program will be instituted in all 8 middle schools during
the first year of this project, providing activity and instruction
which is coordinated with school physical education programs and
directly linked to the state standards for physical education. Beginning
in the second year,(after construction of the new climbing walls)
a rock climbing gym program will be introduced to all eight middle
schools, providing students with five hours of rock climbing instruction
and climbing opportunity during after-school and weekend hours.
This partnership with the City of Eugene in providing this after-school
and rock climbing program, will also allow us to link students with
short-term City Team Adventure experiences in kayaking, cross country
skiing, canoeing, hiking, and low and high rope course initiatives
offered district-wide next year on a sign-up basis. The city is
contributing significant financial support to this component of
the project. (See Appendix 3: Letter of Commitment.)
Research to Support Goal 2
Recognizing the problem of inactivity and declining physical education
time and resources, the Oregon Coalition for Promoting Physical
Activity (2003) calls for an increase in opportunities for youth
to be engaged in daily physical activity outside of physical education
class and for partnerships to facilitate this happening. Both national
and local research (City of Eugene 2003) have recognized transportation,
cost, availability of facilities, and safety among the barriers
to participation in healthy recreational physical activity. This
project removes those barriers while providing not only healthy
recreational physical activity but further opportunities for students
to develop the skills necessary to meet Oregon benchmark standards.
Goal 3: All physical education and after-school program staff will
receive ongoing professional development in a wide range of health-related
lifetime and non-traditional activities aimed at increasing student
interest and enthusiasm for physical activity.
Objective 1: Physical education staff will be provided
with follow-up workshops on Fitnessgram and heart rate monitors
introduced during the 2003-2004 school year in order to move staff
from awareness to institutionalization of those standards-based
changes.
Objective 2: Physical education staff at all grade
levels will receive training in the implementation of assessment
protocols for the state physical education standards.
Objective 3: Physical education staff at all grade
levels will receive in-depth training in dance instruction.
Objective 4: Physical education staff at all levels
and after-school program staff will receive training in cooperative
games and team building activities.
Objective 5: Physical education teachers at all
grade levels will receive training in standards based activities
addressing all three strands of the Oregon physical education standards
provided by National Physical Education Teachers of the Year.
Objective 6: All physical education staff, as well
as science and classroom staff responsible for health instruction,
will receive training in nutrition education.
Objective 7: Middle school and high school physical
education staff will receive training in the Fitness For Life Curriculum.
Objective 8: Elementary and middle school physical
education staff will receive training in the Learning Obstacles
circuit program.
Objective 9: Middle school and high school physical
education and after-school program staff will receive in- depth
training in rock climbing.
Objective 10: Elementary and middle school physical
education staff and after-school program staff will receive staff
training in a wide range of standards-based activities.
Objective 11: After-school program staff will receive
training in the Oregon Content and Student Performance Standards
for Physical Education.
Objective 12: After school program staff will receive
training in liability and safety related to physical education and
activity programs.
Objective 13. Physical Education
staff and after school staff will integrate the new activities and
positive teaching strategies into their evolving programs.
Activities to meet Goal 3 objectives
Two pieces of technology introduced into Eugene programs with the
2003-2004 grant will require follow-up staff training. Training
on both the heart rate monitors and Fitnessgram software, while
excellent, were not sufficient to institutionalize the full integration
of their use in the physical education program. (Oregon Content
Standards: Fitness for a Lifetime 1 and 2)
After completing pilot testing of the district assessment protocols
for the Oregon standards, district-wide training will be needed
on the implementation of the final testing instrument in order to
better insure reliability of the assessment and the data collected
on student achievement.
Dance is an all-inclusive lifetime skill activity and represents
a huge gap in our programs. Full-day Dare to Dance workshops for
elementary and secondary staff, will be provided by Christy Lane,
one of America’s most well-known and respected dance educators.
Local dance instructors will train staff in Hip Hop, a sure bet
to excite our students. The biggest gap and discomfort level with
dance is in our middle school programs. We will contract with Paul
Bodin, a well-known local dance instructor, to work as a peer trainer
with middle school staff. Mr. Bodin will spend 2 weeks in each middle
school working along side staff to present swing, contra and mixers
to all 6th graders.. He will supply each teacher with a syllabus
and a copy of all music used and will review lessons before and
debrief lessons after each class session with the physical education
teacher. (Oregon Standards: Expressive and Efficient Movement 1)
Middle and high school physical education staff and after school
program staff will receive extensive training on indoor rock climbing
to facilitate a successful rock climbing program in both the physical
education and after-school programs. Through this year’s grant,
we were able to provide each elementary school with a low (bouldering)
climbing wall, but lack climbing opportunities in grades 6-12. We
currently have one successful model of top rope climbing operating
in one middle school, a model developed by physical education staff,
administration, risk management personnel, a commercial climbing
gym, and the district insurer. This project would follow this model
to add a 21’ high top rope wall to each of our middle schools.
These walls would allow not only an instructional program in each
middle school but also a zero period (7 a.m.) climbing class for
each high school, and make possible climbing and climbing instruction
for students and families during out of school time through the
city parks and recreation program. The end result will be comprehensive
K-12 articulated climbing program and a citywide program for students
and families. (Oregon Standards: Expressive and Efficient Movement
1 and 3, Social Behavior and Self-Management 1)
While we now have some programs to teach social skills and manage
behavior issues, we need to train physical education staff to integrate
social skill and problem solving techniques into the physical education
curriculum. In the current project we will introduce project adventure
activities late this spring and through the proposed project will
provide additional training in cooperative games and team building
as well as rock climbing to reach this objective. (Oregon Standards:
Social Behavior and Self-Management 1 and 2)
Physical education staff and after-school program staff will be
trained in a variety of standards-based activities using two different
formats. Former Oregon physical education teachers of the year will
provide training in circus sports, cup stacking and elementary fitness
activities. Grade-level specific workshops will be taught by teams
of two elementary, middle school, and high school AAHPERD National
and District Teachers of the Year. Activities will specifically
address and be linked to each of the three strands of the Oregon
standards. A series of 2 four-hour workshops on standards-based
activities during each of the three years of this project will use
a peer trainer model successfully employed in our 2003-2004 PEP
Project. In these workshops, each teacher brings an activity to
present to peers as if actually teaching a class. Each teacher receives
a write-up of the activity with related specific benchmark references
and sources for equipment and supplies. Teachers receive hands-on
experience with all activities and a valuable resource guide for
future reference. In year two of the project, we will send two-person
elementary, middle, and high school teams to the AAHPERD National
Convention to gather new ideas and strategies to be brought back
and shared with others through the peer trainer workshops.
Middle and high school staff will be trained in Fitness for Life,
a comprehensive fitness and health curriculum. Dr. Corbin, internationally
recognized author of Fitness for Life, has expressed an interest
in working with our staff. One section of the Fitness for Life curriculum
focuses on nutrition, an important component of this project. This
year’s project provided all elementary, middle and high school
physical education staff with basic nutrition training on food choices
and eating disorders. So that staff will take a more active role
in nutrition education, we will provide advanced nutrition education
for our physical education staff as well as science and classroom
teachers who share responsibility for health instruction. Nutrition
workshops on the Michigan Model will be provided to K-3, 4-5, and
6-8 staff. A comprehensive school health curriculum, the Michigan
Model has been recognized by Drug Strategies, Inc. as one of the
nation’s top substance abuse prevention programs. Staff will
receive nutrition curriculum materials from this program to use
with students. Another workshop will be provided for all staff on
media influence on the rates of childhood obesity. (Oregon Standards:
Fitness For A Lifetime 1 and 2)
After-school program staff will be provided workshops on the Oregon
Content and Student Performance Standards for Physical Education
and in liability and safety in physical education and activity programs.
The standards workshop will enable the after-school staff to become
true partners with the physical education staff in helping district
students attain benchmark standards. The liability workshop will
give them training in best practices to provide students with stronger
learning experiences as well as safe participation.
Research to Support Goal 3
In Promoting Better Health among Youth through Physical Activity
and Sport (2000), the Secretary of Health and Human Services identifies
appropriately trained physical education teachers as the most essential
ingredient of a quality physical education program. He calls upon
school districts to intensify efforts to provide staff development
for physical educators. In A Healthy Active Oregon: The Statewide
Physical Activity Plan (2003), the Oregon Coalition for Promoting
Physical Activity also calls upon school districts to provide on-going
staff development for physical education teachers. In Guidelines
for School and Community Programs to Promote Lifelong Physical Activity
Among Young People (1997), the CDC identifies lack of proper training
as a barrier to safe, organized, and effective physical education
instruction. The need for ongoing staff development is strongly
supported in NASPE’s publications on Appropriate Practices
for Elementary (2000), Middle School (2001) and High School (1998)
Physical Education.
The Surgeon General (1996) calls for quality staff development.
This project will employ a broad range of quality staff development
opportunities. Workshop presenters for dance, heart rate monitors,
and liability and safety are all nationally recognized leaders in
their fields. AAHPERD national and district teachers of the year
will present grade-level specific workshops in standards-based activities.
They represent the best practitioners in the school setting.
Goal 4: Project staff will develop new school/community
partnerships to provide curriculum relevance and student connection
to community-based activity opportunities.
Objective 1: Strengthen existing partnerships,
develop new partnerships and use community resources to provide
staff development to district physical education staff.
Objective 2: Foster community involvement in physical
education instruction by partnering with at least one agency at
each of the three levels – elementary, middle, and high school.
Activities to meet Goal 4 objectives
During the implementation of the current PEP project, we were able
to successfully develop partnerships with two golf courses, a self-defense
school, and an aerobic fitness facility. This project will continue
to seek out community organizations and businesses as additional
resources to develop, and support students as lifetime consumers
of an active and healthy lifestyle. Establishing connections and
forming partnerships with the community not only enhances but brings
relevance to physical education, as students encounter resources
within the community.
Through this project, we will continue to employ community partners
to lend expertise in providing staff development for successful
implementation of the new physical education program. Community
resources, including the local climbing gym, dance studios, parks
and recreation, and private instructors will prepare staff to implement
the expanded curriculum. These community resources will also be
used as guest instructors to introduce students to opportunities
in the community for lifetime activity. These instructors will reinforce
instruction provided by physical education staff and bring curriculum
relevance to the everyday lives of students.
Research to Support Goal 4
The Oregon Coalition for Promoting Physical Activity reports that
30% of 8th grade students fail to meet the minimum recommendation
of the Surgeon General and the CDC for physical activity. The Coalition
notes that this increases to 50% by the 11th grade. According to
the Coalition, less than 50% of 8th graders attend daily physical
education class while the number drops to less than 20% by grade
11 (2003). Because school programs generally fail to provide the
needed amount of activity within the school, it is critical to help
students make the connections to enjoyable activities of interest
to them and available in the community. It is estimated that over
80% of children’s physical activity occurs outside of physical
education (Heath, Pratt, Warren and Kann, 1994). In its state activity
plan, the Oregon Coalition for Promoting Physical Activity calls
for increasing youth participation in physical activity outside
of school (2003).
Goal 5: Project staff will increase parent opportunities
to support their children’s participation in meaningful health-related
lifetime activity.
Objective 1: To continue encouraging parents to
be healthy role models and facilitators of health-related fitness
within their families.
Activities to Achieve Goal 5 Objectives
This project will continue family fitness nights started this year
at all schools. These family events will continue to encourage and
support family participation in healthy physical activity while
making them more aware of district physical education program goals
and community opportunities for family participation in lifetime
activity. Parents will be kept up to date on individual school physical
education curriculum offerings and events and how they link to the
Oregon standards through physical education news columns in school
parent newsletters.
Research to Support Goal 5
Guidelines for School and Community Programs to Promote Lifelong
Physical Activity Among Young People (2000) encourages parents to
support their children’s participation in physical activity
and be physically active role models. Health Is Academic (Marx,
Wooley, and Northrop, 1998) points out the need to work with families
and the community to develop awareness of the need for physical
activity and encourages physical education teachers to form partnerships
with families for the promotion of lifelong physical activity.
The Rising Expectations: Institutionalizing Change for Lifetime
Fitness project recognizes the critical role of the family in developing
students into lifetime consumers of physical activity and in making
other healthy lifestyle choices. The project will make connections
with home that will facilitate student achievement of the Oregon
Student Performance Standards with the ultimate goal of giving students
the skills, knowledge and attitudes to adopt a lifelong healthy
lifestyle.QUALITY OF THE PROJECT EVALUATION
4 (a). Methods of evaluation and performance measures
The following tables outline the summative evaluation for each goal
of the Rising Expectations project. Each table includes the objectives,
measurement method, schedule of data collection and person responsible
for data collection. The analysis of all data and preparation of
evaluation reports will be the responsibility of the project director,
Dr. James Hart of the Department of Instruction, and project evaluator,
Dr. Dennis Urso, District Evaluation Specialist. The data and analysis
will be shared with all district physical education staff, building
administrators and instruction department administration. It will
be used to further refine the district physical education program
and to make recommendations for continued staff development, community
involvement and parent involvement.
Evaluation Matrix
for Goal 1: Increase in standards-based lifetime activities. |
| Objective |
Measurement |
Schedule |
Responsibility |
| 1:A minimum of 75% of students will be introduced to a new
activity that they enjoyed and had not previously participated
in. |
- Curriculum map
- Student report
- Scale evaluation of new activities
|
|
- Teachers
- Project Director
|
| 2: Percentage of students participating in an average of 30
mins. of moderate physical activity will increase from 71% to
80% |
- Student report
- Annual Healthy Teen Survey
|
- Spring: Years 1, 2, and 3
|
- Teachers
- Project Director
|
| 3: 75% of all students will meet performance benchmarks for
the state physical education standards in the first full year
of assessment in Year 2, 80% in year 3. ß State benchmark
test results |
|
|
- Project Director
- Project Evaluator
|
| 4: A health-related fitness profile of the school District
will be created in Yr. 1 with over-weight 8th grade students
decreasing from 33% to 28% by the end of Yr. 3 |
|
- Spring: Years 1, 2, and 3
|
- Teachers
- Project Director
|
Evaluation Matrix
for Goal 2: Middle school after-school activity programs. |
| Objective |
Measurement |
Schedule |
Responsibility |
| 1: All 8 middle schools will initiate standards-based after-school
activity programs |
- Semester plan of activities
|
|
- After-school staff
- After-school coordinator
- Project Director
|
| 2: All 8 middle schools will initiate after school rock climbing
programs. |
|
|
- City climbing staff
- City Team Adventure coordinator
- Project Director
|
Evaluation Matrix
for Goal 3: Staff Development |
(* Note: CPD’s
are Certificates of Professional Development,
required by the Oregon Department of Education for recertification.) |
| Objective |
Measurement |
Schedule |
Responsibility |
| 1: Physical education staff will be provided with follow-up
workshops on Fitnessgram and heart rate monitors |
- Participation roster for CPD
- Participation evaluation
|
Fall: Year 1 |
|
| 2: Physical education staff will receive training in the implementation
of standards assessment. |
- Participation roster for CPD
- Participation evaluation
|
Fall: Year 2 |
|
| 3: Physical education program staff will be provided in-depth
training in dance.(Peer trainer, Hip Hop, Dare to Dance) |
- Participation roster for CPD
- Participation evaluation
|
Fall: Year 1
Winter: Year 1
Spring: Year 1
Winter: Year 2
Fall: Year 3
|
|
| 4: Physical education and after-school program staff will
be provided with training in cooperative games/ team building |
- Participation roster for CPD
- Participation evaluation
|
Fall: Year 3 |
|
| 5: Physical education staff will receive training in standards
based activities by national Physical Education Teachers of
the Year. |
- Participation roster for CPD
- Participation evaluation
|
Fall: Year 1 |
|
| 6: All physical education staff and science and classroom
staff respon-sible for health instruction will re-ceive training
in nutrition educ-ation.(MI Model and Media Role) |
- Participation roster for CPD
- Participation evaluation
|
Winter: Year 1
Winter: Year 3
|
|
| 7: Middle school and high staff will receive training in the
Fitness For Life Curriculum. |
- Participation roster for CPD
- Participation evaluation
|
Spring: Year 1 |
|
| 8: Elementary and middle school staff will receive training
in non-traditional fitness activities (Learning Obstacles and
more). |
- Participation roster for CPD
- Participation evaluation
|
Winter: Year 2 |
|
| 9: Middle school, high school, and after-school staff will
receive in- depth training in rock climbing |
- Participation roster for CPD
- Participation evaluation
|
Fall: Year 2 |
|
10: Elementary, middle and after-school program staff will receive
peer training in a wide range of standards-based activities |
- Participation roster for CPD
- Participation evaluation
|
2 per year in Winter and Spring |
|
| 11: After-school staff will receive training in Content and
Student Performance Standards for Physical Education. |
|
Fall: Year 1
Fall: Year 2
Fall: Year 3 |
|
| 12: After school program staff will receive liability&
safety training |
|
Fall: Years 1, 2, 3 |
|
| 13. Physical Education and after school staff will integrate
new ac-tivities and positive teaching strat-egies into their
evolving programs |
- Curriculum mapping
- After school activities rosters
|
Spring: Year 1
Spring: Year 2
Spring: Year 3
|
|
Evaluation Matrix
for Goal 4: School/community partnerships |
| Objective |
Measurement |
Schedule |
Responsibility |
| 1: Strengthen existing and develop new partnerships to provide
training to physical education staff. |
|
|
|
| 2: Foster community involvement in physical education instruction
by partnering with at least 3 agencies |
- List of agencies
- Observation
|
|
- Teachers
- Project Director
|
Evaluation Matrix
for Goal 5: 1: Family Connection |
| Objective |
Measurement |
Schedule |
Responsibility |
| 1: To continue encouraging parents to be healthy role models
and facilitators of health-related fitness within their families |
- Schedule of family fitness nights
- Newsletter articles
- Parent survey
|
|
- Teachers
- Project Director
|
4 (b). Performance feedback and periodic assessment.
The plan of evaluation in the tables above is ongoing throughout
the project. The evaluation schedule includes not only collection
of quantitative data but also qualitative data through staff evaluations
and surveys. This ongoing formative evaluation will allow activity
modification when needed to meet or exceed goals. Changes in the
format, timing and content of project activities will be based on
feedback from staff, students and parents. The project Director
will meet at least quarterly, with the Assistant Superintendent
for Instruction and a Project Consultant to evaluate progress and
make needed adjustments. The 2003-04 PEP Project Director (now retired),
will be retained as a consultant to guarantee continuity between
the current project and the proposed project. (See Appendix
4: Vitas)
|