|
Defining the Task: Experienced Researcher
|
- Where can I get ideas?
- What if my topic is too narrow OR broad?
- What are my information requirements?
- Do you understand the assignment?

|
This is the first step
of the information literacy cycle. As a result of new learnings
and understandings, you will constantly revisit this stage during
the entire process. You will refine and redefine the task for further
clarification.
You have been given an assignment. It is your responsibility
to know EXACTLY what the information problem is and what information
is needed. Sometimes choosing a topic is the biggest hurdle in doing
research. Your teacher may assign a general or specific topic, or
the choice may be up to you. Knowing where to look for ideas will
help you find an interesting subject. If the instructions are not
clear, ask your teacher to explain further.
|
Your interests, the things you have been reading, and conversations
you have had in class or with others are often good sources of ideas.
Sources of background information like general encyclopedias,
subject-specific encyclopedias, dictionaries, or textbooks can be sources
of ideas. Check out the reference section of the library. Ask the librarian
for assistance.
Browsing the shelves in the library is also a good way to get an idea
of topics.Do a keyword search of the library database to find out where
books on a certain topic are shelved. Since books are shelved together
by topic, once you have identified the call number of one book, you
can browse that section for related books.
What if my topic is too narrow OR too broad?
|
You may be need to narrow (or sometimes broaden) a topic so that you
can demonstrate a good understanding of it, including enough examples
and important details, within the size limits of the project you are
required to produce. You need to satisfy both yourself and your
teacher that you know what you are talking about. If your teacher gives
you no limits, make them for yourself. You don't want to spend your
life on this, at least not right now.
This is the #1 biggest pitfall in the research process. If you pick
a topic that is too big, you will not only have trouble selecting what
to include from a huge selection of material available, you will probably
leave out some critical information that will make it apparent (especially
to your teacher) that you don't really know what you are talking about.
If, on the other hand, you pick a topic that is too narrow, you won't
find enough to write about and end up repeating yourself to fill 6 pages
(which doesn't go over very well with teachers either, by the way).
The process of narrowing a topic takes practice, so be patient with
yourself. It is challenging when you don't know too much about a topic.
It will get easier as your knowledge base increases. Remember that the
research process is a recursive one which means that you may need to
revisit your topic choice more than once if you find it doesn't work
out. Luckily there are some strategies and methods to help
you through this critically important part of the process.
Say you have to do a research project about World War II, and you don't
know a thing about it, nor are you at all interested in it. Try to find
a subtopic that connects to your interests.*
|
If you like cars, try comparing the land vehicles used by the
Germans and the Americans.
|
| If you like fashion, look
at women's fashions during the war and how they were influenced
by military uniforms and the shortage of certain materials. |
| If you like animals, look
at the use of dogs by the US Armed Forces. |
|
If you like puzzles and brain teasers, look at the fascinating
topic of decoding secret messages.
|
| If you like music, find out
what types of music American teenagers were listening to during
the war years. |
| If you are a pacifist, find
out what the anti-war movement was like during the war in any
country. |
|
Find out what was happening during the war on your birth date.
|
|
Find out if any of your relatives fought in the war and research
that time and place.
|
*Thanks to Holly Samuels, Librarian: Cambridge Rindge
and Latin School, Cambridge, MA USA
Here is another way to approach the narrowing process:
| General
Topic: |
History of Italian
Music |
| Time
Span: |
Since World War
II |
| Person
or Place: |
Dallapiccolo and
Nona |
| Event
or Aspects: |
Opera |
| Narrowed
Topic Sentence: |
The contributions
to opera of Dallapiccolo and Nona |
Boolean Searching
The Boolean operators AND and NOT can be used in database searches
to narrow a search statement. For more information, consult Electronic
Searching.
Topic Broadening
Topics that are too narrow are fairly simple to fix. Think of broader
associations for your subject. For example, if your topic was deforestation
on Colombia's long-term ability to feed its citizens, consider the
following questions:
- Could you examine other countries or regions in addition to Colombia?
- Could you think more broadly about this topic? Give thought to
wider topics like agriculture and sustainable development.
- Who are the key players in this topic? The government? Citizens?
International organizations?
- What other issues are involved in this topic? Such as, how can
natural resources be allocated most economically to sustain the
populace of Colombia?
| Specific
Topic: |
What is the effect
of deforestation on Colombia's long-term ability to feed its citizens? |
| Alternate
Focus: |
Agriculture, sustainable
development |
| Alternate
Place: |
South America |
| Alternate
Person or Group: |
United Nations and
its subgroups |
| Alternate
Event or Aspect: |
Birth Control |
| Broadened
Topic Sentence: |
How can the United
Nations encourage South American countries to employ sustainable
development practices? |
What are my information requirements?
|
When analyzing your assignment, you will also want to consider the
type, quantity, and format of information you will need. Answering
the following questions may help you organize your research:
- What is the due date?
- How much time do I need to spend on this? Do I have dates/time set
aside on my calendar to get it done?
- What kind of assignment do I have to complete? (5 minute oral presentation,
10-page paper, multimedia presentation)
- What do I already know about this topic? If I don't know anything
I need to check sources of background information.
- How much information do I need? What kind of information do I need?
(background, up-to-date)
- What formats do I need? (visual, audio, printed, electronic)
- How will I organize the information? (outline, mind map, chart/matrix)
Do I want to use Inspiration?
- Is point of view an issue? Do you need opinions?
- When I run into a problem who will help me refine or redefine the
project? (my teacher, the librarian, a parent)
Do you understand the assignment?
|
It is important to look for key words in the assignment as they will
tell you what you are supposed to do. Some key words often found in
assignments and questions are:
Analyze:
Divide the topic into parts. Tell how each part is related to the whole.
It means to take apart in such a way that a complete understanding of
the whole can be acquired by a consideration of the parts.
Apply:
To use practically or specifically. An apply question usually asks that
you transfer abstract concepts in everyday or concrete examples.
Assess:
Rate or evaluate something.
Compare:
Decide how things are the same and different. Tell about both the similarities
and differences.
Contrast:
Find the differences between things and tell about the differences.
Criticize:
Explain both the good points and bad points, not just the bad points
as many people think. It means to judge the merits and the faults.
Define:
Explain what it means. Tell how it is like some things and different
than others.
Describe:
To tell in words how a person looks, feels, or acts, or how a place,
a thing, or an event looks or happened.
Discuss:
To talk or write about an issue/topic from all aspects. Careful thought
should be given to a "discuss" assignment.
Evaluate:
Give the positive and negative points, advantages and disadvantages,
pros and cons. Also give your opinion.
Explain:
Clearly tell the details about something, or the reasons or causes for
something. The answer can best be organized in step-by-step organization.
Identify:
To name, to make known, to bring out, to list.
Illustrate:
Describe specific examples. The more examples you can give, the better.
Interpret:
To clarify, to expound or to explain the significance of. It also means
to translate the meaning of. It is often used with famous quotations.
Relate:
Tell how things are connected, what they have in common. Relate may
also mean to narrate or to tell a story.
Summarize:
Present you information in as few words as possible (and in your own
words).
Example:
How did New Deal programs influence the arts in America?
Keywords:
New Deal
United States
Great Depression
Art
Federal Aid to the Arts
|
|

Please send comments or questions to the 4J
Web Team.
Eugene School District 4J
200 North Monroe Street, Eugene, Oregon 97402
Phone: 541.687.3123 [TTD 541.687.3447]

Last modified: October 6 by Steinke, Ague, Feuerhelm, Maxwell, and Warburg
|